Dark Dialogue Podcast Network

Dark Dialogue: Gallows and Gunfights - Billy The Kid Part 3: The House Always Wins — Until It Doesn’t

Before Billy the Kid ever drew his gun, before the Regulators ever swore vengeance, Lincoln County was already lost—sold, signed, and sealed by a handful of men who turned commerce into tyranny.
In Dark Dialogue: Gallows & Gunfights – The House Always Wins — Until It Doesn’t, John and Angela open the record on the empire that ruled the New Mexico Territory through ledgers, credit, and fear. From Lawrence Murphy’s mercantile monopoly to James Dolan’s violent enforcement, from John Riley’s quiet corruption to Jesse Evans’ bloody loyalty, this episode traces the roots of the Lincoln County War to their true source: greed.
Follow the rise and fall of The House—the cartel that bought a county, buried its rivals, and learned too late that even empires built on fear eventually crumble. Featuring detailed historical reconstructions, courtroom-style storytelling, and immersive sound design, this installment of Gallows & Gunfights takes you straight into the smoke and politics of the Old West’s most infamous feud.
🔔 Listen Now on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or YouTube.👍 Like, Follow, and Leave a Review to help others find the show.📢 Share this episode with anyone who still thinks the Old West was simple—because the truth is darker than the legend.💀 Join the Dark Dialogue Collective and explore more untold cases at www.darkdialogue.com.📧 Send your thoughts, theories, or case tips to info@darkdialogue.com.🕯️ And remember… The jury of history never adjourns.Let the past take the stand — and the guilty face the gallows.

Dark Dialogue - Trial by Technology – Justice for April | The Digital Evidence That Spoke for Her

When fourteen-year-old April Millsap left home to walk her dog on a warm July evening in 2014, no one in the quiet town of Armada, Michigan could have imagined the horror that would follow. Hours later, her loyal dog Penny came home alone — and a small community was forever changed.
In this episode of Dark Dialogue, John and Angela take you inside the groundbreaking trial that proved a killer’s guilt without a single eyewitness or confession. Through fitness app GPS data, cell tower triangulation, and digital breadcrumbs, investigators pieced together the final minutes of April’s life — and exposed James VanCallis, a local man whose lies collapsed under the weight of the data.
From the FBI’s 63-minute Google Earth animation of April’s last walk to the haunting testimony of her mother and boyfriend, “Trial by Technology – Justice for April” reveals how modern forensic science gave a voice to a victim who could no longer speak for herself. This case redefined how technology serves justice — and how data, once cold and clinical, can become the most powerful witness of all.
💔 Featuring:
April’s final GPS trail reconstructed step by step
Eyewitness accounts and expert testimony that stunned the courtroom
The digital evidence that led to a life-without-parole conviction
A heartfelt tribute to April Marie Millsap — forever 14
🎙️ Join John and Angela as they expose how data became the storyteller, justice found its footing in zeros and ones, and a mother’s strength turned tragedy into advocacy.
If this story moved you, please follow, rate, and share the podcast. Your support keeps these cases alive — and ensures no victim is ever forgotten.
🔗 Learn more and get involved:
Adopt-a-Victim Program → www.darkdialogue.com
Join the Dark Dialogue Collective to support investigations
Subscribe on Substack for research files, extended case notes, and behind-the-scenes analysis
Email: info@darkdialogue.com
Keep searching.Keep questioning.Keep remembering.And above all… keep the dialogue alive.

Dark Dialogue: Rocky Mountain Reckoning - Lisa Marie Kimmell Part 3: A Cold Silence

Silence can be louder than any answer.
In this episode of Rocky Mountain Reckoning: Dark Dialogue, John and Angela revisit the long, painful years after the 1988 murder of Lisa Marie Kimmell—the bright 18-year-old whose life was stolen along a Wyoming highway. For more than a decade, her family lived with grief and questions while investigators faced false leads, dead ends, and mounting frustration.
You’ll hear about:
The dead-end years (1988–2002): false confessions, cult rumors, and missed opportunities that let Lisa’s killer walk free.
The Stringfellow Hawke letter: a cryptic note left on Lisa’s grave that haunted her family for years—later tied directly to the man who murdered her.
The emotional toll: how birthdays, holidays, and long nights of waiting wore on Lisa’s parents, sisters, and community.
The broader pattern: a chilling reminder that Lisa was not the only woman to vanish across the highways and plains of the American West.
This is the story of frustration, silence, and resilience—the fight of a family who refused to let Lisa be forgotten, even when the system faltered.
If Lisa’s story moves you, don’t let it fade into silence.👉 Follow and subscribe to Dark Dialogue on your favorite podcast platform.👉 Leave us a rating or review—it helps keep these victims’ names alive.👉 Share this episode with someone who cares about justice.👉 Join our community for bonus content and case files at darkdialoguecrime.substack.com.👉 Support our investigative work directly at patreon.com/DarkDialoguepod or ko-fi.com/darkdialogue.
Every listen, every share, and every show of support helps us keep the dialogue alive—and ensures that stories like Lisa’s are never forgotten.

Darl Dialogue: Gallows and Gunfights - The Regulators Ride On

The roll call of the Regulators is not complete. In this second installment of Dark Dialogue: Gallows and Gunfights, John and Angela return to the witness stand of history to finish the testimony of the men who stood with Billy the Kid during the Lincoln County War.
Bound together by the cold-blooded murder of John Tunstall, the Regulators were ranch hands, drifters, and lawmen who became vigilantes in a county where the law itself had collapsed. Some would go on to wear badges, others to outlawry, and a few would simply vanish into the desert winds. Their fates diverged, but their bond was forged in blood.
This episode explores the stories of Henry Newton Brown, Fred Waite, John Middleton, George and Frank Coe, Jim French, and Yginio Salazar — men caught in a crucible where vigilante justice was often the only justice left. Their individual verdicts remain open, but as a group, their case reveals the harsh reality of the Old West: survival often required stepping outside the law.
Join us as we weigh their legacy, withholding judgment on the Lincoln County War itself until the House — Murphy, Dolan, and Riley — takes the stand in future episodes.
If you enjoy the show, subscribe on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or YouTube. Leave a review to help others discover our courtroom of history, and share the episode with anyone who loves the untold truths of the Wild West. To support the work, visit us on Patreon, Ko-fi, or Substack. You can also take part in the Adopt-a-Victim Program or join the Dark Dialogue Collective to help bring justice to forgotten cases.
The jury of history never adjourns. Let the past take the stand — and the guilty face the gallows.

Dark Dialogue: Shadow Chat Sessions - Ocean Hamsters, Time Cubes, and Crimes of Absolute Idiocy

What do you get when a man tries to run across the Atlantic Ocean in a floating hamster wheel? 
In this episode, John and Angela kick things off with one of Florida’s finest maritime meltdowns — a man attempting to “jog” to London across the sea in a duct-taped hamster wheel.Then we head straight into Time Cube madness, where one man’s war on science birthed the most chaotic conspiracy website in internet history. Over in the Reddit Rabbit Hole, we explore The Backrooms — an endless, fluorescent-lit horror dimension where geometry, monsters, and your last shred of sanity go to die.
Dipshit Diaries returns with three new criminal masterminds:
One used a clear plastic bag as a disguise,
One posted selfies with stolen bank money,
And one left a pizza box with his name and address at the crime scene.
Then, in Weird Shit, we bring you:🦍 The Nandi Bear, Kenya’s cryptid hyena-beast☠️ The posthumous execution of Oliver Cromwell🧟‍♂️ The Six Million Dollar Man wax corpse discovery🍖 Issei Sagawa, the cannibal who became a celebrity🍝 A viral TikTok cold-water pasta war that nearly broke the internet
It’s dumb. It’s bizarre. It’s educational in all the wrong ways.Join us as we keep the dialogue weird.
💬 Stay connected:🌐 darkdialogue.com☕ patreon.com/darkdialogue🕵️ Apply to join the Dark Dialogue Collective🎙️ Adopt-a-Victim and help solve cold cases

Dark Dialogue: April Milsap Episode 3 | The Man on the Dirt Bike – Building the Case

When a 14-year-old’s evening walk ends in tragedy, the town of Armada, Michigan is shaken to its core. In this episode of Dark Dialogue, John and Angela dissect the early investigation that turned a nameless “man on the dirt bike” into a household name—and a prime suspect.
Follow the crucial leads that shaped the case:
Eyewitness accounts of a helmeted rider who shouldn’t have been on the trail.
Digital footprints from April’s phone and Sports Tracker app, mapping her final desperate moments.
Family secrets and fractured loyalty within the VanCallis household that helped dismantle an alibi.
Through testimony, technology, and relentless persistence, investigators painstakingly pieced together a case where DNA and weapons were absent—but the truth spoke through data, memory, and detail.
You’ll hear the emotional weight of a town in turmoil, a family divided by loyalty and truth, and a victim whose story continues to echo far beyond Armada. This is the moment rumor became evidence, technology converged with testimony, and the fight for justice gained its first decisive momentum.
✨ Dark Dialogue brings you atmospheric storytelling, forensic deep dives, and unflinching humanity at the center of every case.
📢 Calls to Action
If you believe every story deserves to be heard:
Follow & Subscribe on your favorite podcast platform.
Share April’s story to keep her memory alive.
Join us on Patreon or Ko-fi to support independent, victim-centered investigations.
Take action through our Adopt-a-Victim program or become part of the Dark Dialogue Collective to help amplify cases still searching for answers.
April Millsap mattered. Her story continues—one lead, one listener, one dialogue at a time.

Dark Dialogue Shadow Chat Sessions: Double Jackpots, Backroom Realms, and Dumb Criminal Energy

This episode of Shadow Chat Sessions is a chaotic blend of dumb luck, dumber criminals, and deeply weird mysteries—just the way we like it.
John and Angela unpack the story of a Maryland man who won the Powerball twice in the same drawing, and dive into the latest Reddit rabbit hole: the Finn McMillan note mystery, filled with alien pleas and identity crises.In Conspiracy Corner, they tackle the viral panic around Project 2025 and the idea of a shadow government takeover. Then it's time for Dipshit Diaries, where criminals forget to wear real disguises, post selfies with stolen money, and literally leave pizza receipts at the crime scene.Weird Shit wraps it all up with fresh cryptid sightings, a haunted axe-call house, a newly uncovered Mayan city, a toucan toilet rescue, and a man proudly breaking the world record for 96 wet sponges to the face.
💀 It’s smart. It’s stupid. It’s everything in between.
💬 Talk to us🛠️ darkdialogue.com☕ patreon.com/darkdialogue🕵 Adopt-a-Victim or join the Dark Dialogue Collective!

Dark Dialogue: Rocky Mountain Reckoning - Lisa Marie Kimmell Part 2 - What the River Gave Back – The Discovery of Lisa

🕯️ What the River Gave Back dives into the chilling moment Lisa Marie Kimmell was found—eight days after her disappearance—in the frigid waters of the North Platte River. Naked. Weighted down. Brutally assaulted. And discarded like she didn’t matter.
But Lisa mattered.And this episode lays bare the horror of what was done to her—and the haunting silence that followed.
We unpack:
The forensic evidence recovered in 1988—and what it couldn’t yet reveal
The iconic “LIL MISS” license plate that became a symbol of both heartbreak and hope
The media storm that swept through Wyoming and Montana, changing public fear forever
The critical investigative failures that let a killer walk free for 14 years
The family’s courage in demanding answers when no one else could deliver them
💔 Lisa’s story wasn’t just a headline. It was a reckoning. And in this episode, we begin to understand what the river gave back—and what it couldn’t wash away.
🎧 Listen now and make the guilty face the reckoning.
✅ Support the Mission
🧾 Get full transcripts, case files, and exclusive content: darkdialoguecrime.substack.com
☕ Fuel the investigation with a one-time gift: ko-fi.com/darkdialogue
💬 Join the discussion on Discord: discord.gg/MeghDycm
📬 Contact us: info@darkdialogue.com
🔔 Subscribe. Follow. Share.Every click helps us keep the dialogue alive—and bring forgotten victims back into focus.

Dark Dialogue: Gallows and Gunfights - Billy the Kid, Part 1 – The Regulators Rise

The courtroom of the Old West is open — and our first witness is Billy the Kid.
In the debut of Dark Dialogue: Gallows and Gunfights, we strip away the dime-novel myths to uncover how Henry McCarty — a bright, polite boy from the slums of New York — became William H. Bonney, the young Regulator at the center of the Lincoln County War.
This episode follows his journey from crowded tenements in Manhattan to the rough mining town of Silver City, where hardship, loss, and survival forged the boy who would one day be called an outlaw. You’ll meet the Regulators as they first step onto the stage — Dick Brewer, Charlie Bowdre, Frank McNab, and Doc Scurlock — men caught between law and lawlessness, loyalty and bloodshed.
This isn’t Hollywood’s West. It’s the messy, brutal truth: where lawmen carried warrants one day and rifles the next, and justice was often written in smoke and gunpowder.
👉 Follow or subscribe on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or YouTube so you don’t miss the next session.👍 Leave us a review to help bring these forgotten histories into the light.📢 Share this episode with a friend who loves the Old West — and let them be the jury too.
Because in this courtroom of history, you decide: outlaw or lawman?

Dark Dialogue Shadow Chat Sessions: Robot Chicken Fights, Fog Bioweapons, and Desert Journals: Weirdness Level 9000

Get ready for an all-you-can-eat buffet of bizarre, brain-bending, and hilariously horrifying headlines in this episode of Shadow Chat Sessions — where the weird doesn’t just visit, it moves in and redecorates.
🗞️ Strange Headline:Legalized Robot Chicken Fights in Oklahoma — Yep, it’s real. Remote-controlled roosters armed with buzzsaws and titanium beaks are going toe-to-toe in state-sanctioned battle arenas. John breaks down the science, the chaos, and why the snack bar at these events might be the most disturbing part.
🧪 Conspiracy Corner:Fogvid-24 — The Chemical Fog Bioweapon — A weird-smelling fog rolls across the Midwest, and the internet goes full tinfoil. Is it atmospheric science? A drone-delivered mind-control gas? Or just an elaborate cover for Olive Garden’s new scent marketing?
🕳️ Reddit Rabbit Hole:The Desert Journal Mystery — A cryptic journal filled with codes, missing persons references, and GPS coordinates appears online... and then disappears, along with the Redditor who posted it. Real mystery? ARG? Government prank? Let’s dig into the dirt.
🚓 Dipshit Diaries:
Manual Transmission Meltdown — A teen carjacker is foiled by the ancient technology known as “stick shift.”
Bat vs. Bullets — Derrick Mosley brings a baseball bat to a gun store robbery. Guess how that ends.
Mushroom Ritual Gone Wrong — A man lights his car on fire, strips naked, and takes a soap bath in a Wisconsin lake. The reason? “Mushroom rebirth.”
🐰 Weird Shit Segment:
Cryptid: The Bunny Man of Virginia – Axe-wielding rabbit-man? Welcome to America.
Paranormal: The Evil in Room 611 – Poltergeists, screams, and one unlucky scientist named Ken.
Historical WTF: Gladiator vs. Lion in Ancient York – Actual bones prove Roman Britain wasn’t just tea and sandals.
Modern Trend: Hamstering in Cars – The new sex trend that’ll ruin your floor mats forever.
Tech & Divination: AI Coffee Reading Causes Divorce – An algorithm tells her he’s cheating. She files for divorce. Reality is broken.
🎙️ John’s Take:Wielding sarcasm like a blessed artifact, John dives headfirst into the madness—grilling dumb criminals, mocking technomancers, and unpacking cryptid chaos with the sardonic grace of a caffeinated warlock.
📢 Like what you hear? Then do your part:
👍 Follow, rate, and review us wherever you listen.🔁 Share this episode with your most chaotic friend.🎧 Support the show on Patreon for early access and bonus weirdness.🕵️‍♂️ Want to get involved?
Adopt a Victim and help us investigate unsolved cases
Join the Dark Dialogue Collective to support real-world searches and advocacy.
Keep it weird. Keep it real. Keep the dialogue alive.